Reliable Flight Search results
Best trips
8 nonstop, 32 with 1 connection · ranked by overall best · published legroom for 40 of 40
Fares seen on this date: nonstop from 193 · any route from 155 (recent searches, one way, per person; each card opens the live price)
Our best overall pick
90% chance you arrive on time · nonstop · 30 in legroom · planes about 4 years old · 3h 03m
Top pick#1 · Nonstop · 3h 03m
7:50 AM → 10:53 AM
74
score
price
live on Aviasales
90%
arrive on time
91% on time · 1.6% cancel7:50 AM EWR → 10:53 AM RSW3h 03m
United 1237
Boeing 737 MAX 9 · 0–10 yrs oldLegroom 30–31 in · 16.3–17.8 in wide · United EconomyFind United 1237 fares Opens this date on Aviasales#2 · Nonstop · 3h 07m
6:45 AM → 9:49 AM
68
score
price
live on Aviasales
87%
arrive on time
88% on time · 2.0% cancel6:45 AM EWR → 9:49 AM RSW3h 07m
United 1115 · also flew as 1991
Boeing 737-900ER or 737 MAX 8 · 1–17 yrs oldLegroom 30–31 in · 16.3–17.8 in wide · United EconomyFind United 1115 fares Opens this date on Aviasales#3 · Nonstop · 3h 00m
2:54 PM → 5:54 PM
60
score
price
live on Aviasales
79%
arrive on time
80% on time · 1.2% cancel2:54 PM EWR → 5:54 PM RSW3h 00m
United 1832
Boeing 737 MAX 8 · 1–12 yrs oldLegroom 30–31 in · 16.3–17.8 in wide · United EconomyFind United 1832 fares Opens this date on Aviasales#4 · 1 connection · 5h 36m · one ticket (United)
6:10 AM → 11:46 AM
58
score
price
live on Aviasales
94%
connections made
88%
arrive on time
95% on time · 2.0% cancel6:10 AM EWR → 7:28 AM IAD1h 18m
United 1366
Boeing 737 MAX 8 or 737-900ER · 1–17 yrs oldLegroom 30–31 in · 16.3–17.8 in wide · United EconomyConnect in IAD · 1h 32m · 97% chance to make it · same ticket: the airline rebooks you if you miss it93% on time · 0.5% cancel9:00 AM IAD → 11:46 AM RSW2h 46m
United 1406
Boeing 737 MAX 8 or 737-900ER · 2–17 yrs oldLegroom 30–31 in · 16.3–17.8 in wide · United EconomyFind this United trip Look for United 1366 + United 1406 on Aviasales#5 · Nonstop · 3h 12m
11:08 AM → 2:15 PM
58
score
price
live on Aviasales
78%
arrive on time
80% on time · 2.4% cancel11:08 AM EWR → 2:15 PM RSW3h 12m
United 738
Boeing 737 MAX 9 or 737 MAX 8 · 0–8 yrs oldLegroom 30–31 in · 16.3–17.8 in wide · United EconomyFind United 738 fares Opens this date on Aviasales#6 · Nonstop · 3h 02m
1:26 PM → 4:28 PM
57
score
price
live on Aviasales
82%
arrive on time
83% on time · 1.6% cancel1:26 PM EWR → 4:28 PM RSW3h 02m
JetBlue 1911
Airbus A320 · 19–24 yrs oldLegroom 30–34 in · 17.8–18.4 in wide · CoreFind JetBlue 1911 fares Opens this date on Aviasales#7 · Nonstop · 3h 14m
7:07 PM → 10:25 PM
54
score
price
live on Aviasales
75%
arrive on time
76% on time · 1.3% cancel7:07 PM EWR → 10:25 PM RSW3h 14m
United 435
Boeing 737 MAX 9 · 0–13 yrs oldLegroom 30–31 in · 16.3–17.8 in wide · United EconomyFind United 435 fares Opens this date on Aviasales#8 · Nonstop · 3h 05m
1:55 PM → 4:57 PM
52
score
price
live on Aviasales
78%
arrive on time
80% on time · 2.6% cancel1:55 PM EWR → 4:57 PM RSW3h 05m
JetBlue 1811
Airbus A320 · 17–24 yrs oldLegroom 30–34 in · 17.8–18.4 in wide · CoreFind JetBlue 1811 fares Opens this date on Aviasales#9 · Nonstop · 3h 13m
5:32 PM → 8:45 PM
52
score
price
live on Aviasales
76%
arrive on time
77% on time · 1.5% cancel5:32 PM EWR → 8:45 PM RSW3h 13m
United 1222
Boeing 737-900ER · 10–18 yrs oldLegroom 30–31 in · 16.3–17.8 in wide · United EconomyFind United 1222 fares Opens this date on Aviasales#10 · 1 connection · 5h 18m · one ticket (American)
7:42 AM → 1:00 PM
41
score
price
live on Aviasales
91%
connections made
76%
arrive on time
95% on time · 2.9% cancel7:42 AM EWR → 9:50 AM CLT2h 08m
American 2505
Boeing 737-800 · 2–26 yrs oldLegroom 30 in · 16.3–18.7 in wide · Main CabinConnect in CLT · 1h 12m · 95% chance to make it · same ticket: the airline rebooks you if you miss it84% on time · 1.6% cancel11:02 AM CLT → 1:00 PM RSW1h 58m
American 2684
Boeing 737-800 · 10–26 yrs oldLegroom 30–32 in · 16.3–18.7 in wide · Main CabinFind this American trip Look for American 2505 + American 2684 on Aviasales
Aircraft and ages come from the planes each flight number actually flew in the last 3 months of data (FAA registry build years); airlines can swap planes. Legroom is the seat pitch the airline or a seat-map source publishes for that aircraft and cabin; we never estimate it, and seat maps change, so check the airline’s seat map when you book.
EWR → RSW
Newark to Fort Myers: 2,030 nonstop flights a year
On time (12 months)
80%
Cancelled
1.8%
avg delay 14 min
Best time to leave
Before 9 AM
90% on time vs 73% 6 to 9 PM
Most reliable airline
JetBlue
80% chance on time
Lowest nonstop fare seen in the next two months: $193 (United 738 on 2026-11-18). Fares open on our travel partner (Aviasales). Pick the flight number you chose here.
Airlines on this route
Season-adjusted chance of operating and arriving on time.
- JetBlue80%
327 flights · 81% on time as flown · 2.0% cancel
- United Airlines79%
1,703 flights · 80% on time as flown · 1.8% cancel
On time by departure time
All airlines, scheduled local departure, Jun 2025 to May 2026.
- Before 9 AM90%
585 flights · avg delay 7 min
- 9 AM to noon78%
350 flights · avg delay 15 min
- Noon to 3 PM81%
295 flights · avg delay 12 min
- 3 to 6 PM76%
342 flights · avg delay 16 min
- 6 to 9 PM73%
455 flights · avg delay 21 min
Best day: Tuesday (84%). Worst: Sunday (73%).
Smarter routing
Nearby airports that run more on time
HPN → RSW 81% chance on time
Westchester County Airport to Southwest Florida International Airport · 654 flights a year · 36 mi from your airports · yours: 79%
Historical odds, not a guarantee. Built from the US DOT Bureau of Transportation Statistics on-time reports (Jun 2025 to May 2026), FAA ground stop and delay program advisories, and 20 years of airport weather observations. Covers US airlines that report to the DOT; schedules are flights operated recently, so confirm times when you book. ATIS Alerts is not affiliated with any airline. Fares are what Aviasales travelers saw in recent searches (USD, one way, 1 adult), not live quotes; the partner site shows the current price. Fare links go to our travel partner and may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Affiliate disclosure
